According to Christine Farquharson, associate director of the Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS), companies that employ a large number of low-wage workers will be the most negatively impacted by the budget's measures, which will leave early years providers and, eventually, staff in a worse financial situation in the absence of increased government funding.
In her first budget, Chancellor Rachel Reeves reiterated her commitment to the increase in supported childcare hours proposed in March 2023 by her predecessor, Jeremy Hunt. Due to the scope of that deployment, overall spending is expected to increase by GBP1.8 billion in the upcoming year, following the same course that Mr. Hunt had outlined. It's a significant shift, but not a novel one.
The way the Budget reshapes cost pressures, especially around staffing, is where the major effect for early years settings lies.
Increasing Employer Expenses
The Budget makes significant changes to employer National Insurance Contributions (NICs), lowering the annual threshold at which NICs begin to accrue from around GBP9,100 to GBP5,000 and raising the rate from 13.8% to 15%.
These developments especially impact lower-paid workers. The employer's NICs payment will increase by more than a third, from approximately GBP2,200 to nearly GBP3,000, for a typical full-time childcare worker making GBP25,000.
While public institutions such as schools and colleges will receive compensation for these increased expenses, private childcare providers will not receive the same level of assistance. The private sector still provides the majority of pre-school childcare in England, even though 80% of it is expected to be publicly supported.
Increases in the National Living Wage
A significant increase in the minimum wage, which will rise by 77p per hour to GBP12.21, will also be borne by providers starting in April. The hike is even more pronounced for workers between the ages of 18 and 20, whose minimum pay has increased to GBP10 per hour.
Many early childhood educators who make the minimum wage or less will be happy to hear this. However, it also poses a financial issue for suppliers. A significant increase in the minimum wage will have a significant effect on costs because staffing accounts for about three-quarters of the budgets of most childcare facilities.
Employers find it more difficult to "pass on" their increased costs in the form of lower salaries when the minimum wage is raised. Workers will ultimately experience smaller pay increases and lower salaries, accounting for an average of almost 60% of the impact of the NICs tax increase. However, this transition is far more challenging for daycare providers because many of their staff are currently paid at or close to minimum wage.
Repercussions for Smaller Enterprises
By increasing the Employment Allowance, which now offers a refund on the first GBP10,500 of employer NICs, the government has provided some assistance. An employer with four full-time minimum wage workers might avoid paying NICs at the current minimum wage rate.
Companies that employ a large number of low-wage workers will be most affected by this budget. Higher wages and NICs will result in higher personnel costs, and the Employment Allowance will only cover a smaller percentage of their payroll.
Will Increasing Costs Be Reflected in Funding Rates?
Whether government funding rates will rise to pay these additional costs is a crucial question. There are no additional funds in the budget for the childcare industry to make up for increased NICs or wages. Any changes to funding would therefore have to come from other sources, which would put more strain on larger budgetary plans.
financing rates for the new entitlements for two-year-olds and under-twos are far greater than the average price they charge parents, and the early years sector has lately witnessed a significant rise in financing. However, pressure will increase due to the Budget's revisions, particularly for larger settings. A key test of the government's response to this will be the upcoming spring Spending Review.